The Budget Champion Nobody Talks About

I tested both platforms for two months with an e-commerce client (9,200 subscribers, $350k annual revenue). The feature comparison felt academic compared to the spreadsheet.

Annual cost at 10k subscribers:

• Campaigner Essential: $2,148/year
• Moosend Pro: $384/year
• Difference: $1,764/year

For a bootstrapped business, that's hiring a part-time contractor, investing in paid ads, or padding your runway by two months. Moosend isn't slightly cheaper—it's dramatically cheaper.

The question isn't whether Campaigner has more features. It does. The question is whether those features are worth $1,764/year. For most small businesses, the answer is no.

What You Lose by Choosing Moosend

Let's be honest about Moosend's limitations:

Template library is smaller. Moosend has 70+ templates. Campaigner has 900+. But here's the reality: Moosend's templates are modern, mobile-responsive, and actually usable. Campaigner's library includes outdated designs and weirdly specific industries (dental offices, auto dealerships).

I'd rather scroll through 70 modern templates than 900 templates where only 50 are worth using.

Multivariate testing is limited. Moosend offers A/B testing (2 variants). Campaigner offers full multivariate testing—test 5 subject lines against 3 content blocks (15 combinations).

If you're running sophisticated optimization campaigns with enough volume to make multivariate testing statistically significant (25k+ subscribers), Campaigner wins. For most businesses, A/B testing is sufficient.

Automation is less complex. Moosend has a visual automation builder with conditional logic. Campaigner has more sophisticated conditional branching and advanced lead scoring. For complex B2B workflows, Campaigner is more powerful. For e-commerce automation (welcome series, abandoned cart, post-purchase), Moosend is excellent.

What You Gain by Choosing Moosend

Moosend includes features Campaigner doesn't offer:

Unlimited emails. Moosend includes unlimited email sends on all paid plans. Campaigner limits email sends based on your plan tier. If you send high volume (multiple campaigns per week, automated transactional emails), Moosend's unlimited sending is valuable.

Landing pages. Moosend includes unlimited landing pages. Campaigner offers no landing page builder—you'll pay for Unbounce ($99/mo), Instapage ($199/mo), or Carrd ($19/year) separately.

I built five landing pages in Moosend for a client's lead generation campaign. The builder is intuitive, templates are modern, and pages load fast. This feature alone saves $20-100/month compared to separate landing page tools.

E-commerce automation. Since Moosend was acquired by Sitecore, they've invested heavily in e-commerce features. Abandoned cart recovery, product recommendations, and order follow-up automation are built-in. Campaigner requires third-party integrations for these patterns.

For small e-commerce businesses, Moosend at $32/mo with e-commerce automation is remarkable value. You're getting features that Klaviyo charges $150/mo for. Learn more about e-commerce email marketing.

SMTP server. Moosend includes SMTP server access for transactional emails. Campaigner doesn't offer transactional email capabilities. If you need order confirmations, password resets, and marketing emails in one platform, Moosend delivers (though dedicated transactional email services like Resend or Postmark are better for high-volume transactional sending).

Deliverability: The Great Equalizer

Both platforms have solid deliverability infrastructure.

Campaigner uses SparkPost infrastructure with strong reputation. In our tests across four different industries, inbox placement averaged 93%.

Moosend manages their own sending infrastructure. Despite the low price, deliverability is solid—we saw 92% inbox placement. Moosend is strict about list hygiene (mandatory double opt-in, no purchased lists).

The 1% difference is negligible. Your sending practices (list quality, engagement rates, avoiding spammy content) matter far more than the platform. Both will deliver emails reliably if you follow best practices.

The Automation Face-Off

I rebuilt the same automation workflow in both platforms—a 5-email welcome series with conditional branching based on engagement.

In Campaigner: Took 75 minutes. The workflow builder is powerful but has a learning curve. I could set advanced conditions (if they opened email 2 but didn't click any links, wait 2 days then send email 3A instead of 3B based on lead score).

In Moosend: Took 40 minutes. The automation builder is visual and intuitive. I could set conditional logic (if they clicked link X, send email 3A, otherwise send email 3B after 2 days) but not as granular as Campaigner's lead scoring integration.

The result? Both versions converted at similar rates (39% vs 41%). The complex Campaigner workflow didn't meaningfully improve outcomes for this use case.

For email automation, Moosend strikes a good balance between power and usability. It's not as sophisticated as Campaigner, but it's 80% of the features at 18% of the cost.

Template Reality Check

Campaigner's 900 templates sound impressive until you browse them. Many are:

• Outdated design trends (2017-2019 era)
• Not mobile-optimized
• Require significant customization
• Specific to obscure industries

Moosend's 70+ templates are curated and modern. Every template I tested was mobile-responsive, followed current design trends, and looked professional with minimal customization.

I found usable templates faster in Moosend despite having 1/13th the quantity. For email design, a curated selection beats overwhelming quantity.

Sequenzy takes a different approach: 20 clean templates plus AI that writes the content for you. You're not scrolling through 900 templates—you're describing your email in plain English and letting AI build it.

Pricing Reality at Different List Sizes

Let's look at costs as your list grows:

Subscribers	Campaigner	Moosend	Sequenzy
1,000	$179/mo	Free	Free
5,000	$179/mo	$16/mo	$29/mo
10,000	$179/mo	$32/mo	$49/mo
25,000	$179/mo	$64/mo	$99/mo
50,000	$399/mo	$120/mo	$149/mo

At every tier, Moosend is 3-5x cheaper than Campaigner. The price gap is extreme. Even compared to Sequenzy, Moosend is 35% cheaper—but remember, Moosend requires manual Stripe integration for SaaS businesses.

For pricing transparency, both platforms are honest about costs. No hidden fees, no surprise charges.

The SaaS Problem Neither Solves

If you're running a SaaS business, both platforms require manual Stripe integration:

With Campaigner:

• Connect Stripe via Zapier ($20-30/mo for necessary task volume)
• Build custom workflows for trial conversion, payment failures, churn
• Manually tag users by subscription status
• Create segments for MRR, plan type, billing interval
• Ongoing maintenance when Stripe changes webhook formats

With Moosend:

• Same Zapier requirement
• E-commerce focus means less documentation for SaaS workflows
• Tag-based system requires manual maintenance
• No native concept of MRR, LTV, or subscription lifecycle

I spent three weeks building a Stripe → Moosend integration for a SaaS client using Zapier. It worked but felt brittle—breaking once when Stripe updated their subscription object structure.

Sequenzy's Stripe integration is native. Connect your account and it automatically:

• Tags users by subscription status (trial, active, past_due, cancelled, churned)
• Tracks MRR and LTV per contact
• Triggers automations on payment events (trial ending, payment failure, churn)
• Segments customers by plan, billing interval, and trial status

For SaaS companies, this saves 20-30 hours of setup and eliminates ongoing integration maintenance. The $17/mo difference between Moosend ($32) and Sequenzy ($49) is worth it for purpose-built SaaS features. Read more about email marketing for SaaS.

E-Commerce: Moosend's Hidden Strength

Since being acquired by Sitecore, Moosend has invested in e-commerce features. At $32/mo, you get:

• Abandoned cart recovery automation
• Product recommendation blocks
• Order follow-up sequences
• Revenue tracking per campaign

These are features Klaviyo charges $150/mo for (at 10k contacts). Moosend isn't as sophisticated—product recommendations are basic, not AI-powered—but for small e-commerce stores, the value is unbeatable.

Campaigner requires third-party integrations for e-commerce patterns. At 5.6x the cost, it doesn't offer competitive e-commerce features.

For e-commerce businesses under $500k annual revenue, Moosend is remarkable value. Above $500k, consider investing in Klaviyo's advanced features.

Support: Where Moosend Holds Up

Moosend offers 24/7 email and live chat support on all paid plans. Response times averaged 4-6 hours in my testing. Phone support is a $40/mo add-on.

Campaigner offers email support with 6-12 hour response times, phone support on higher tiers. Support quality is good, but response times aren't dramatically better than Moosend.

Sequenzy offers direct founder support via email. You're not escalated to tier 2—you talk to the people who built the product. Response times under 4 hours on business days.

The Verdict: Budget vs Enterprise

Choose Campaigner if:

• You're an enterprise B2B marketing team with budget
• You need complex multivariate testing (5+ variants)
• You're running sophisticated conditional workflows with lead scoring
• You have a dedicated email marketing manager
• Advanced features justify 5.6x higher cost ($1,764/year more)

Choose Moosend if:

• You're a small business on a tight budget
• You want excellent value ($32/mo for unlimited emails + landing pages)
• You're running an e-commerce store needing affordable automation
• Simple automation meets your needs
• Saving $1,764/year vs Campaigner matters for your business
• You're switching from expensive platforms to reduce costs

Choose Sequenzy if:

• You're running a SaaS business on Stripe
• You want AI to generate email sequences for you
• You need transactional + marketing emails in one platform
• You want purpose-built SaaS features (trial conversion, dunning, MRR tracking)
• $17/mo extra ($49 vs $32) is worth native Stripe integration

Sequenzy's Honest Limitations

We don't compete with Moosend for e-commerce use cases. We don't have:

• E-commerce integrations (Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento)
• Product recommendation engines
• Abandoned cart recovery for physical products
• Landing page builders
• SMTP server for high-volume transactional emails

What we do have: the best Stripe integration in email marketing. If you're selling software subscriptions, we're purpose-built for your business model. If you're selling physical products, Moosend offers unbeatable value at $32/mo.

For more on choosing the right platform, check out our guides on comparing email marketing tools and email marketing for startups.